{
  "accounting_notice": "Candidate graphs, synthesized plans, and volunteer retrieval probes are tracked separately from Stage-1 orthogonal-family acceptance and Stage-2 holdout measured benefit. The no-extra-material baseline stays eligible on every challenge board.",
  "arena_endpoint": "/api/v1/pipeline/arena",
  "challenges": [
    {
      "best_composition_plan": {
        "beats_no_extra_material_baseline": true,
        "card_chain": [
          "parse_scene_det",
          "synthesize_motion_hybrid"
        ],
        "edges": [
          {
            "from_vertex": "v1_parse_scene_det",
            "to_vertex": "v2_synthesize_motion_hybrid"
          }
        ],
        "estimated_cost_usd": 0.012,
        "estimated_latency_ms": 638,
        "estimated_tokens": 2800,
        "latency_ms": 638,
        "model_calls": 1,
        "plan_id": "plan_8cb92dd2dc075ff8",
        "quality_score": 0.9694,
        "recommended_submission_lane": "lane_11_compose_solution_graph",
        "savings_vs_baseline": {
          "model_calls_saved": 3,
          "tokens_saved": 13200,
          "usd_saved": 0.053
        },
        "source_bodies_loaded": 0,
        "swhid_chain": [
          "swh:1:cnt:1111111111111111111111111111111111111111",
          "swh:1:cnt:4444444444444444444444444444444444444444"
        ],
        "total_tokens": 2800,
        "unchanged_components_reused": 2,
        "vertex_count": 2,
        "vertices": [
          {
            "card_id": "parse_scene_det",
            "deterministic": true,
            "input_type": "raw_scene_brief/v1",
            "model_calls": 0,
            "output_type": "parsed_scene_graph/v1",
            "source": "reused_card",
            "vertex_id": "v1_parse_scene_det",
            "vertex_kind": "loop"
          },
          {
            "card_id": "synthesize_motion_hybrid",
            "deterministic": false,
            "input_type": "parsed_scene_graph/v1",
            "model_calls": 1,
            "output_type": "verified_motion_pack/v1",
            "source": "reused_card",
            "vertex_id": "v2_synthesize_motion_hybrid",
            "vertex_kind": "loop"
          }
        ],
        "zero_model_deterministic": false
      },
      "bridge_opportunities": [
        {
          "from_card_id": "extract_cad_brep",
          "from_output_schema": "cad_brep_mesh/v1",
          "suggested_bridge_spec": {
            "deterministic": true,
            "input_type": "cad_brep_mesh/v1",
            "model_calls": 0,
            "output_type": "rigged_skeleton/v1",
            "vertex_kind": "loop"
          },
          "target_lane": "lane_14_edge_bridge_adapter",
          "target_queue": "q04_solve",
          "to_card_id": "pack_gltf_rig",
          "to_input_schema": "rigged_skeleton/v1",
          "unlocked_chain_cost_usd": 0.0,
          "unlocked_chain_quality": 0.9506
        },
        {
          "from_card_id": "parse_scene_det",
          "from_output_schema": "parsed_scene_graph/v1",
          "suggested_bridge_spec": {
            "deterministic": true,
            "input_type": "parsed_scene_graph/v1",
            "model_calls": 0,
            "output_type": "rigged_skeleton/v1",
            "vertex_kind": "loop"
          },
          "target_lane": "lane_14_edge_bridge_adapter",
          "target_queue": "q04_solve",
          "to_card_id": "pack_gltf_rig",
          "to_input_schema": "rigged_skeleton/v1",
          "unlocked_chain_cost_usd": 0.0,
          "unlocked_chain_quality": 0.9312
        },
        {
          "from_card_id": "extract_cad_brep",
          "from_output_schema": "cad_brep_mesh/v1",
          "suggested_bridge_spec": {
            "deterministic": true,
            "input_type": "cad_brep_mesh/v1",
            "model_calls": 0,
            "output_type": "parsed_scene_graph/v1",
            "vertex_kind": "loop"
          },
          "target_lane": "lane_14_edge_bridge_adapter",
          "target_queue": "q04_solve",
          "to_card_id": "synthesize_motion_det",
          "to_input_schema": "parsed_scene_graph/v1",
          "unlocked_chain_cost_usd": 0.0,
          "unlocked_chain_quality": 0.9016
        }
      ],
      "catalog_cards": [
        {
          "card_id": "parse_scene_det",
          "estimated_cost_usd": 0.0,
          "estimated_tokens": 0,
          "input_type": "raw_scene_brief/v1",
          "latency_ms": 18,
          "loop_mode": "deterministic",
          "model_calls": 0,
          "output_type": "parsed_scene_graph/v1",
          "quality_prior": 0.96,
          "swhid": "swh:1:cnt:1111111111111111111111111111111111111111",
          "title": "Deterministic scene manifest parser"
        },
        {
          "card_id": "parse_scene_llm",
          "estimated_cost_usd": 0.018,
          "estimated_tokens": 4200,
          "input_type": "raw_scene_brief/v1",
          "latency_ms": 950,
          "loop_mode": "hybrid",
          "model_calls": 1,
          "output_type": "parsed_scene_graph/v1",
          "quality_prior": 0.91,
          "swhid": "swh:1:cnt:2222222222222222222222222222222222222222",
          "title": "Model-assisted scene brief interpreter"
        },
        {
          "card_id": "synthesize_motion_det",
          "estimated_cost_usd": 0.0,
          "estimated_tokens": 0,
          "input_type": "parsed_scene_graph/v1",
          "latency_ms": 35,
          "loop_mode": "deterministic",
          "model_calls": 0,
          "output_type": "verified_motion_pack/v1",
          "quality_prior": 0.92,
          "swhid": "swh:1:cnt:3333333333333333333333333333333333333333",
          "title": "Parametric keyframe motion solver"
        },
        {
          "card_id": "synthesize_motion_hybrid",
          "estimated_cost_usd": 0.012,
          "estimated_tokens": 2800,
          "input_type": "parsed_scene_graph/v1",
          "latency_ms": 620,
          "loop_mode": "hybrid",
          "model_calls": 1,
          "output_type": "verified_motion_pack/v1",
          "quality_prior": 0.99,
          "swhid": "swh:1:cnt:4444444444444444444444444444444444444444",
          "title": "Hybrid style-guided motion composer"
        },
        {
          "card_id": "extract_cad_brep",
          "estimated_cost_usd": 0.0,
          "estimated_tokens": 0,
          "input_type": "raw_scene_brief/v1",
          "latency_ms": 22,
          "loop_mode": "deterministic",
          "model_calls": 0,
          "output_type": "cad_brep_mesh/v1",
          "quality_prior": 0.98,
          "swhid": "swh:1:cnt:5555555555555555555555555555555555555555",
          "title": "STEP B-Rep topology extractor"
        },
        {
          "card_id": "pack_gltf_rig",
          "estimated_cost_usd": 0.0,
          "estimated_tokens": 0,
          "input_type": "rigged_skeleton/v1",
          "latency_ms": 25,
          "loop_mode": "deterministic",
          "model_calls": 0,
          "output_type": "verified_motion_pack/v1",
          "quality_prior": 0.97,
          "swhid": "swh:1:cnt:6666666666666666666666666666666666666666",
          "title": "Rigged glTF motion exporter"
        }
      ],
      "challenge_id": "ch_creative_motion_01",
      "cheapest_pareto_plan": {
        "beats_no_extra_material_baseline": true,
        "card_chain": [
          "parse_scene_det",
          "synthesize_motion_det"
        ],
        "edges": [
          {
            "from_vertex": "v1_parse_scene_det",
            "to_vertex": "v2_synthesize_motion_det"
          }
        ],
        "estimated_cost_usd": 0.0,
        "estimated_latency_ms": 53,
        "estimated_tokens": 0,
        "latency_ms": 53,
        "model_calls": 0,
        "plan_id": "plan_9f7a8a5f7d019a4e",
        "quality_score": 0.9185,
        "recommended_submission_lane": "lane_12_cheapest_pareto_solution",
        "savings_vs_baseline": {
          "model_calls_saved": 4,
          "tokens_saved": 16000,
          "usd_saved": 0.065
        },
        "source_bodies_loaded": 0,
        "swhid_chain": [
          "swh:1:cnt:1111111111111111111111111111111111111111",
          "swh:1:cnt:3333333333333333333333333333333333333333"
        ],
        "total_tokens": 0,
        "unchanged_components_reused": 2,
        "vertex_count": 2,
        "vertices": [
          {
            "card_id": "parse_scene_det",
            "deterministic": true,
            "input_type": "raw_scene_brief/v1",
            "model_calls": 0,
            "output_type": "parsed_scene_graph/v1",
            "source": "reused_card",
            "vertex_id": "v1_parse_scene_det",
            "vertex_kind": "loop"
          },
          {
            "card_id": "synthesize_motion_det",
            "deterministic": true,
            "input_type": "parsed_scene_graph/v1",
            "model_calls": 0,
            "output_type": "verified_motion_pack/v1",
            "source": "reused_card",
            "vertex_id": "v2_synthesize_motion_det",
            "vertex_kind": "loop"
          }
        ],
        "zero_model_deterministic": true
      },
      "deterministic_substitutions": [
        {
          "model_calls_saved": 1,
          "replace_card_id": "synthesize_motion_hybrid",
          "target_lane": "lane_12_cheapest_pareto_solution",
          "tokens_saved_per_call": 2800,
          "typed_edge": "parsed_scene_graph/v1 -> verified_motion_pack/v1",
          "usd_saved_per_call": 0.012,
          "with_deterministic_card_id": "synthesize_motion_det",
          "with_swhid": "swh:1:cnt:3333333333333333333333333333333333333333"
        },
        {
          "model_calls_saved": 1,
          "replace_card_id": "parse_scene_llm",
          "target_lane": "lane_12_cheapest_pareto_solution",
          "tokens_saved_per_call": 4200,
          "typed_edge": "raw_scene_brief/v1 -> parsed_scene_graph/v1",
          "usd_saved_per_call": 0.018,
          "with_deterministic_card_id": "parse_scene_det",
          "with_swhid": "swh:1:cnt:1111111111111111111111111111111111111111"
        }
      ],
      "no_extra_material_baseline": {
        "entry_id": "baseline:no_extra_material",
        "estimated_cost_usd": 0.065,
        "latency_ms": 3400,
        "model_calls": 4,
        "quality_score": 0.72,
        "total_tokens": 16000
      },
      "pareto_frontier_plans": [
        {
          "beats_no_extra_material_baseline": true,
          "card_chain": [
            "parse_scene_det",
            "synthesize_motion_hybrid"
          ],
          "edges": [
            {
              "from_vertex": "v1_parse_scene_det",
              "to_vertex": "v2_synthesize_motion_hybrid"
            }
          ],
          "estimated_cost_usd": 0.012,
          "estimated_latency_ms": 638,
          "estimated_tokens": 2800,
          "latency_ms": 638,
          "model_calls": 1,
          "plan_id": "plan_8cb92dd2dc075ff8",
          "quality_score": 0.9694,
          "recommended_submission_lane": "lane_11_compose_solution_graph",
          "savings_vs_baseline": {
            "model_calls_saved": 3,
            "tokens_saved": 13200,
            "usd_saved": 0.053
          },
          "source_bodies_loaded": 0,
          "swhid_chain": [
            "swh:1:cnt:1111111111111111111111111111111111111111",
            "swh:1:cnt:4444444444444444444444444444444444444444"
          ],
          "total_tokens": 2800,
          "unchanged_components_reused": 2,
          "vertex_count": 2,
          "vertices": [
            {
              "card_id": "parse_scene_det",
              "deterministic": true,
              "input_type": "raw_scene_brief/v1",
              "model_calls": 0,
              "output_type": "parsed_scene_graph/v1",
              "source": "reused_card",
              "vertex_id": "v1_parse_scene_det",
              "vertex_kind": "loop"
            },
            {
              "card_id": "synthesize_motion_hybrid",
              "deterministic": false,
              "input_type": "parsed_scene_graph/v1",
              "model_calls": 1,
              "output_type": "verified_motion_pack/v1",
              "source": "reused_card",
              "vertex_id": "v2_synthesize_motion_hybrid",
              "vertex_kind": "loop"
            }
          ],
          "zero_model_deterministic": false
        },
        {
          "beats_no_extra_material_baseline": true,
          "card_chain": [
            "parse_scene_det",
            "synthesize_motion_det"
          ],
          "edges": [
            {
              "from_vertex": "v1_parse_scene_det",
              "to_vertex": "v2_synthesize_motion_det"
            }
          ],
          "estimated_cost_usd": 0.0,
          "estimated_latency_ms": 53,
          "estimated_tokens": 0,
          "latency_ms": 53,
          "model_calls": 0,
          "plan_id": "plan_9f7a8a5f7d019a4e",
          "quality_score": 0.9185,
          "recommended_submission_lane": "lane_12_cheapest_pareto_solution",
          "savings_vs_baseline": {
            "model_calls_saved": 4,
            "tokens_saved": 16000,
            "usd_saved": 0.065
          },
          "source_bodies_loaded": 0,
          "swhid_chain": [
            "swh:1:cnt:1111111111111111111111111111111111111111",
            "swh:1:cnt:3333333333333333333333333333333333333333"
          ],
          "total_tokens": 0,
          "unchanged_components_reused": 2,
          "vertex_count": 2,
          "vertices": [
            {
              "card_id": "parse_scene_det",
              "deterministic": true,
              "input_type": "raw_scene_brief/v1",
              "model_calls": 0,
              "output_type": "parsed_scene_graph/v1",
              "source": "reused_card",
              "vertex_id": "v1_parse_scene_det",
              "vertex_kind": "loop"
            },
            {
              "card_id": "synthesize_motion_det",
              "deterministic": true,
              "input_type": "parsed_scene_graph/v1",
              "model_calls": 0,
              "output_type": "verified_motion_pack/v1",
              "source": "reused_card",
              "vertex_id": "v2_synthesize_motion_det",
              "vertex_kind": "loop"
            }
          ],
          "zero_model_deterministic": true
        }
      ],
      "required_input_type": "raw_scene_brief/v1",
      "required_output_type": "verified_motion_pack/v1",
      "summary": "Order small contract cards from a scene brief into a verified motion pack without loading source bodies or regenerating working parsers.",
      "title": "Compose an editable 3D scene and motion pack",
      "zero_model_plan": {
        "beats_no_extra_material_baseline": true,
        "card_chain": [
          "parse_scene_det",
          "synthesize_motion_det"
        ],
        "edges": [
          {
            "from_vertex": "v1_parse_scene_det",
            "to_vertex": "v2_synthesize_motion_det"
          }
        ],
        "estimated_cost_usd": 0.0,
        "estimated_latency_ms": 53,
        "estimated_tokens": 0,
        "latency_ms": 53,
        "model_calls": 0,
        "plan_id": "plan_9f7a8a5f7d019a4e",
        "quality_score": 0.9185,
        "recommended_submission_lane": "lane_12_cheapest_pareto_solution",
        "savings_vs_baseline": {
          "model_calls_saved": 4,
          "tokens_saved": 16000,
          "usd_saved": 0.065
        },
        "source_bodies_loaded": 0,
        "swhid_chain": [
          "swh:1:cnt:1111111111111111111111111111111111111111",
          "swh:1:cnt:3333333333333333333333333333333333333333"
        ],
        "total_tokens": 0,
        "unchanged_components_reused": 2,
        "vertex_count": 2,
        "vertices": [
          {
            "card_id": "parse_scene_det",
            "deterministic": true,
            "input_type": "raw_scene_brief/v1",
            "model_calls": 0,
            "output_type": "parsed_scene_graph/v1",
            "source": "reused_card",
            "vertex_id": "v1_parse_scene_det",
            "vertex_kind": "loop"
          },
          {
            "card_id": "synthesize_motion_det",
            "deterministic": true,
            "input_type": "parsed_scene_graph/v1",
            "model_calls": 0,
            "output_type": "verified_motion_pack/v1",
            "source": "reused_card",
            "vertex_id": "v2_synthesize_motion_det",
            "vertex_kind": "loop"
          }
        ],
        "zero_model_deterministic": true
      }
    },
    {
      "best_composition_plan": {
        "beats_no_extra_material_baseline": true,
        "card_chain": [
          "csv_unicode_norm_det",
          "minhash_plus_tiebreak_hybrid"
        ],
        "edges": [
          {
            "from_vertex": "v1_csv_unicode_norm_det",
            "to_vertex": "v2_minhash_plus_tiebreak_hybrid"
          }
        ],
        "estimated_cost_usd": 0.006,
        "estimated_latency_ms": 394,
        "estimated_tokens": 1400,
        "latency_ms": 394,
        "model_calls": 1,
        "plan_id": "plan_db60f2c166b456d0",
        "quality_score": 0.9896,
        "recommended_submission_lane": "lane_11_compose_solution_graph",
        "savings_vs_baseline": {
          "model_calls_saved": 4,
          "tokens_saved": 22600,
          "usd_saved": 0.086
        },
        "source_bodies_loaded": 0,
        "swhid_chain": [
          "swh:1:cnt:7777777777777777777777777777777777777777",
          "swh:1:cnt:aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa"
        ],
        "total_tokens": 1400,
        "unchanged_components_reused": 2,
        "vertex_count": 2,
        "vertices": [
          {
            "card_id": "csv_unicode_norm_det",
            "deterministic": true,
            "input_type": "raw_customer_csv/v1",
            "model_calls": 0,
            "output_type": "normalized_rows/v1",
            "source": "reused_card",
            "vertex_id": "v1_csv_unicode_norm_det",
            "vertex_kind": "loop"
          },
          {
            "card_id": "minhash_plus_tiebreak_hybrid",
            "deterministic": false,
            "input_type": "normalized_rows/v1",
            "model_calls": 1,
            "output_type": "verified_entity_table/v1",
            "source": "reused_card",
            "vertex_id": "v2_minhash_plus_tiebreak_hybrid",
            "vertex_kind": "loop"
          }
        ],
        "zero_model_deterministic": false
      },
      "bridge_opportunities": [],
      "catalog_cards": [
        {
          "card_id": "csv_unicode_norm_det",
          "estimated_cost_usd": 0.0,
          "estimated_tokens": 0,
          "input_type": "raw_customer_csv/v1",
          "latency_ms": 14,
          "loop_mode": "deterministic",
          "model_calls": 0,
          "output_type": "normalized_rows/v1",
          "quality_prior": 0.98,
          "swhid": "swh:1:cnt:7777777777777777777777777777777777777777",
          "title": "RFC 4180 and Unicode NFC table normalizer"
        },
        {
          "card_id": "csv_prompt_cleaner_llm",
          "estimated_cost_usd": 0.028,
          "estimated_tokens": 6400,
          "input_type": "raw_customer_csv/v1",
          "latency_ms": 1200,
          "loop_mode": "hybrid",
          "model_calls": 2,
          "output_type": "normalized_rows/v1",
          "quality_prior": 0.89,
          "swhid": "swh:1:cnt:8888888888888888888888888888888888888888",
          "title": "Prompt-based CSV row normalizer"
        },
        {
          "card_id": "minhash_cluster_det",
          "estimated_cost_usd": 0.0,
          "estimated_tokens": 0,
          "input_type": "normalized_rows/v1",
          "latency_ms": 29,
          "loop_mode": "deterministic",
          "model_calls": 0,
          "output_type": "verified_entity_table/v1",
          "quality_prior": 0.91,
          "swhid": "swh:1:cnt:9999999999999999999999999999999999999999",
          "title": "MinHash LSH near-duplicate blocker"
        },
        {
          "card_id": "minhash_plus_tiebreak_hybrid",
          "estimated_cost_usd": 0.006,
          "estimated_tokens": 1400,
          "input_type": "normalized_rows/v1",
          "latency_ms": 380,
          "loop_mode": "hybrid",
          "model_calls": 1,
          "output_type": "verified_entity_table/v1",
          "quality_prior": 0.99,
          "swhid": "swh:1:cnt:aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa",
          "title": "MinHash blocker with borderline tie-breaker"
        }
      ],
      "challenge_id": "ch_tabular_dedup_02",
      "cheapest_pareto_plan": {
        "beats_no_extra_material_baseline": true,
        "card_chain": [
          "csv_unicode_norm_det",
          "minhash_cluster_det"
        ],
        "edges": [
          {
            "from_vertex": "v1_csv_unicode_norm_det",
            "to_vertex": "v2_minhash_cluster_det"
          }
        ],
        "estimated_cost_usd": 0.0,
        "estimated_latency_ms": 43,
        "estimated_tokens": 0,
        "latency_ms": 43,
        "model_calls": 0,
        "plan_id": "plan_e6705403b049a8d4",
        "quality_score": 0.9275,
        "recommended_submission_lane": "lane_12_cheapest_pareto_solution",
        "savings_vs_baseline": {
          "model_calls_saved": 5,
          "tokens_saved": 24000,
          "usd_saved": 0.092
        },
        "source_bodies_loaded": 0,
        "swhid_chain": [
          "swh:1:cnt:7777777777777777777777777777777777777777",
          "swh:1:cnt:9999999999999999999999999999999999999999"
        ],
        "total_tokens": 0,
        "unchanged_components_reused": 2,
        "vertex_count": 2,
        "vertices": [
          {
            "card_id": "csv_unicode_norm_det",
            "deterministic": true,
            "input_type": "raw_customer_csv/v1",
            "model_calls": 0,
            "output_type": "normalized_rows/v1",
            "source": "reused_card",
            "vertex_id": "v1_csv_unicode_norm_det",
            "vertex_kind": "loop"
          },
          {
            "card_id": "minhash_cluster_det",
            "deterministic": true,
            "input_type": "normalized_rows/v1",
            "model_calls": 0,
            "output_type": "verified_entity_table/v1",
            "source": "reused_card",
            "vertex_id": "v2_minhash_cluster_det",
            "vertex_kind": "loop"
          }
        ],
        "zero_model_deterministic": true
      },
      "deterministic_substitutions": [
        {
          "model_calls_saved": 1,
          "replace_card_id": "minhash_plus_tiebreak_hybrid",
          "target_lane": "lane_12_cheapest_pareto_solution",
          "tokens_saved_per_call": 1400,
          "typed_edge": "normalized_rows/v1 -> verified_entity_table/v1",
          "usd_saved_per_call": 0.006,
          "with_deterministic_card_id": "minhash_cluster_det",
          "with_swhid": "swh:1:cnt:9999999999999999999999999999999999999999"
        },
        {
          "model_calls_saved": 2,
          "replace_card_id": "csv_prompt_cleaner_llm",
          "target_lane": "lane_12_cheapest_pareto_solution",
          "tokens_saved_per_call": 6400,
          "typed_edge": "raw_customer_csv/v1 -> normalized_rows/v1",
          "usd_saved_per_call": 0.028,
          "with_deterministic_card_id": "csv_unicode_norm_det",
          "with_swhid": "swh:1:cnt:7777777777777777777777777777777777777777"
        }
      ],
      "no_extra_material_baseline": {
        "entry_id": "baseline:no_extra_material",
        "estimated_cost_usd": 0.092,
        "latency_ms": 4800,
        "model_calls": 5,
        "quality_score": 0.74,
        "total_tokens": 24000
      },
      "pareto_frontier_plans": [
        {
          "beats_no_extra_material_baseline": true,
          "card_chain": [
            "csv_unicode_norm_det",
            "minhash_plus_tiebreak_hybrid"
          ],
          "edges": [
            {
              "from_vertex": "v1_csv_unicode_norm_det",
              "to_vertex": "v2_minhash_plus_tiebreak_hybrid"
            }
          ],
          "estimated_cost_usd": 0.006,
          "estimated_latency_ms": 394,
          "estimated_tokens": 1400,
          "latency_ms": 394,
          "model_calls": 1,
          "plan_id": "plan_db60f2c166b456d0",
          "quality_score": 0.9896,
          "recommended_submission_lane": "lane_11_compose_solution_graph",
          "savings_vs_baseline": {
            "model_calls_saved": 4,
            "tokens_saved": 22600,
            "usd_saved": 0.086
          },
          "source_bodies_loaded": 0,
          "swhid_chain": [
            "swh:1:cnt:7777777777777777777777777777777777777777",
            "swh:1:cnt:aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa"
          ],
          "total_tokens": 1400,
          "unchanged_components_reused": 2,
          "vertex_count": 2,
          "vertices": [
            {
              "card_id": "csv_unicode_norm_det",
              "deterministic": true,
              "input_type": "raw_customer_csv/v1",
              "model_calls": 0,
              "output_type": "normalized_rows/v1",
              "source": "reused_card",
              "vertex_id": "v1_csv_unicode_norm_det",
              "vertex_kind": "loop"
            },
            {
              "card_id": "minhash_plus_tiebreak_hybrid",
              "deterministic": false,
              "input_type": "normalized_rows/v1",
              "model_calls": 1,
              "output_type": "verified_entity_table/v1",
              "source": "reused_card",
              "vertex_id": "v2_minhash_plus_tiebreak_hybrid",
              "vertex_kind": "loop"
            }
          ],
          "zero_model_deterministic": false
        },
        {
          "beats_no_extra_material_baseline": true,
          "card_chain": [
            "csv_unicode_norm_det",
            "minhash_cluster_det"
          ],
          "edges": [
            {
              "from_vertex": "v1_csv_unicode_norm_det",
              "to_vertex": "v2_minhash_cluster_det"
            }
          ],
          "estimated_cost_usd": 0.0,
          "estimated_latency_ms": 43,
          "estimated_tokens": 0,
          "latency_ms": 43,
          "model_calls": 0,
          "plan_id": "plan_e6705403b049a8d4",
          "quality_score": 0.9275,
          "recommended_submission_lane": "lane_12_cheapest_pareto_solution",
          "savings_vs_baseline": {
            "model_calls_saved": 5,
            "tokens_saved": 24000,
            "usd_saved": 0.092
          },
          "source_bodies_loaded": 0,
          "swhid_chain": [
            "swh:1:cnt:7777777777777777777777777777777777777777",
            "swh:1:cnt:9999999999999999999999999999999999999999"
          ],
          "total_tokens": 0,
          "unchanged_components_reused": 2,
          "vertex_count": 2,
          "vertices": [
            {
              "card_id": "csv_unicode_norm_det",
              "deterministic": true,
              "input_type": "raw_customer_csv/v1",
              "model_calls": 0,
              "output_type": "normalized_rows/v1",
              "source": "reused_card",
              "vertex_id": "v1_csv_unicode_norm_det",
              "vertex_kind": "loop"
            },
            {
              "card_id": "minhash_cluster_det",
              "deterministic": true,
              "input_type": "normalized_rows/v1",
              "model_calls": 0,
              "output_type": "verified_entity_table/v1",
              "source": "reused_card",
              "vertex_id": "v2_minhash_cluster_det",
              "vertex_kind": "loop"
            }
          ],
          "zero_model_deterministic": true
        }
      ],
      "required_input_type": "raw_customer_csv/v1",
      "required_output_type": "verified_entity_table/v1",
      "summary": "Replace multi-call prompt cleaning with deterministic locale normalization, locality-sensitive hashing, and one ambiguity resolver.",
      "title": "Deduplicate and normalize multilingual records",
      "zero_model_plan": {
        "beats_no_extra_material_baseline": true,
        "card_chain": [
          "csv_unicode_norm_det",
          "minhash_cluster_det"
        ],
        "edges": [
          {
            "from_vertex": "v1_csv_unicode_norm_det",
            "to_vertex": "v2_minhash_cluster_det"
          }
        ],
        "estimated_cost_usd": 0.0,
        "estimated_latency_ms": 43,
        "estimated_tokens": 0,
        "latency_ms": 43,
        "model_calls": 0,
        "plan_id": "plan_e6705403b049a8d4",
        "quality_score": 0.9275,
        "recommended_submission_lane": "lane_12_cheapest_pareto_solution",
        "savings_vs_baseline": {
          "model_calls_saved": 5,
          "tokens_saved": 24000,
          "usd_saved": 0.092
        },
        "source_bodies_loaded": 0,
        "swhid_chain": [
          "swh:1:cnt:7777777777777777777777777777777777777777",
          "swh:1:cnt:9999999999999999999999999999999999999999"
        ],
        "total_tokens": 0,
        "unchanged_components_reused": 2,
        "vertex_count": 2,
        "vertices": [
          {
            "card_id": "csv_unicode_norm_det",
            "deterministic": true,
            "input_type": "raw_customer_csv/v1",
            "model_calls": 0,
            "output_type": "normalized_rows/v1",
            "source": "reused_card",
            "vertex_id": "v1_csv_unicode_norm_det",
            "vertex_kind": "loop"
          },
          {
            "card_id": "minhash_cluster_det",
            "deterministic": true,
            "input_type": "normalized_rows/v1",
            "model_calls": 0,
            "output_type": "verified_entity_table/v1",
            "source": "reused_card",
            "vertex_id": "v2_minhash_cluster_det",
            "vertex_kind": "loop"
          }
        ],
        "zero_model_deterministic": true
      }
    },
    {
      "best_composition_plan": {
        "beats_no_extra_material_baseline": true,
        "card_chain": [
          "extract_json_schema_det",
          "corner_case_fuzzer_det"
        ],
        "edges": [
          {
            "from_vertex": "v1_extract_json_schema_det",
            "to_vertex": "v2_corner_case_fuzzer_det"
          }
        ],
        "estimated_cost_usd": 0.0,
        "estimated_latency_ms": 53,
        "estimated_tokens": 0,
        "latency_ms": 53,
        "model_calls": 0,
        "plan_id": "plan_7c947b36b3acd818",
        "quality_score": 0.9884,
        "recommended_submission_lane": "lane_12_cheapest_pareto_solution",
        "savings_vs_baseline": {
          "model_calls_saved": 3,
          "tokens_saved": 11500,
          "usd_saved": 0.048
        },
        "source_bodies_loaded": 0,
        "swhid_chain": [
          "swh:1:cnt:bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb",
          "swh:1:cnt:cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc"
        ],
        "total_tokens": 0,
        "unchanged_components_reused": 2,
        "vertex_count": 2,
        "vertices": [
          {
            "card_id": "extract_json_schema_det",
            "deterministic": true,
            "input_type": "mcp_server_manifest/v1",
            "model_calls": 0,
            "output_type": "typed_tool_edges/v1",
            "source": "reused_card",
            "vertex_id": "v1_extract_json_schema_det",
            "vertex_kind": "loop"
          },
          {
            "card_id": "corner_case_fuzzer_det",
            "deterministic": true,
            "input_type": "typed_tool_edges/v1",
            "model_calls": 0,
            "output_type": "conformance_verdict_pack/v1",
            "source": "reused_card",
            "vertex_id": "v2_corner_case_fuzzer_det",
            "vertex_kind": "loop"
          }
        ],
        "zero_model_deterministic": true
      },
      "bridge_opportunities": [],
      "catalog_cards": [
        {
          "card_id": "extract_json_schema_det",
          "estimated_cost_usd": 0.0,
          "estimated_tokens": 0,
          "input_type": "mcp_server_manifest/v1",
          "latency_ms": 11,
          "loop_mode": "deterministic",
          "model_calls": 0,
          "output_type": "typed_tool_edges/v1",
          "quality_prior": 0.99,
          "swhid": "swh:1:cnt:bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb",
          "title": "JSON Schema edge contract extractor"
        },
        {
          "card_id": "corner_case_fuzzer_det",
          "estimated_cost_usd": 0.0,
          "estimated_tokens": 0,
          "input_type": "typed_tool_edges/v1",
          "latency_ms": 42,
          "loop_mode": "deterministic",
          "model_calls": 0,
          "output_type": "conformance_verdict_pack/v1",
          "quality_prior": 0.96,
          "swhid": "swh:1:cnt:cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc",
          "title": "Deterministic Unicode, timezone, and bounds checker"
        }
      ],
      "challenge_id": "ch_protocol_audit_03",
      "cheapest_pareto_plan": {
        "beats_no_extra_material_baseline": true,
        "card_chain": [
          "extract_json_schema_det",
          "corner_case_fuzzer_det"
        ],
        "edges": [
          {
            "from_vertex": "v1_extract_json_schema_det",
            "to_vertex": "v2_corner_case_fuzzer_det"
          }
        ],
        "estimated_cost_usd": 0.0,
        "estimated_latency_ms": 53,
        "estimated_tokens": 0,
        "latency_ms": 53,
        "model_calls": 0,
        "plan_id": "plan_7c947b36b3acd818",
        "quality_score": 0.9884,
        "recommended_submission_lane": "lane_12_cheapest_pareto_solution",
        "savings_vs_baseline": {
          "model_calls_saved": 3,
          "tokens_saved": 11500,
          "usd_saved": 0.048
        },
        "source_bodies_loaded": 0,
        "swhid_chain": [
          "swh:1:cnt:bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb",
          "swh:1:cnt:cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc"
        ],
        "total_tokens": 0,
        "unchanged_components_reused": 2,
        "vertex_count": 2,
        "vertices": [
          {
            "card_id": "extract_json_schema_det",
            "deterministic": true,
            "input_type": "mcp_server_manifest/v1",
            "model_calls": 0,
            "output_type": "typed_tool_edges/v1",
            "source": "reused_card",
            "vertex_id": "v1_extract_json_schema_det",
            "vertex_kind": "loop"
          },
          {
            "card_id": "corner_case_fuzzer_det",
            "deterministic": true,
            "input_type": "typed_tool_edges/v1",
            "model_calls": 0,
            "output_type": "conformance_verdict_pack/v1",
            "source": "reused_card",
            "vertex_id": "v2_corner_case_fuzzer_det",
            "vertex_kind": "loop"
          }
        ],
        "zero_model_deterministic": true
      },
      "deterministic_substitutions": [],
      "no_extra_material_baseline": {
        "entry_id": "baseline:no_extra_material",
        "estimated_cost_usd": 0.048,
        "latency_ms": 2600,
        "model_calls": 3,
        "quality_score": 0.68,
        "total_tokens": 11500
      },
      "pareto_frontier_plans": [
        {
          "beats_no_extra_material_baseline": true,
          "card_chain": [
            "extract_json_schema_det",
            "corner_case_fuzzer_det"
          ],
          "edges": [
            {
              "from_vertex": "v1_extract_json_schema_det",
              "to_vertex": "v2_corner_case_fuzzer_det"
            }
          ],
          "estimated_cost_usd": 0.0,
          "estimated_latency_ms": 53,
          "estimated_tokens": 0,
          "latency_ms": 53,
          "model_calls": 0,
          "plan_id": "plan_7c947b36b3acd818",
          "quality_score": 0.9884,
          "recommended_submission_lane": "lane_12_cheapest_pareto_solution",
          "savings_vs_baseline": {
            "model_calls_saved": 3,
            "tokens_saved": 11500,
            "usd_saved": 0.048
          },
          "source_bodies_loaded": 0,
          "swhid_chain": [
            "swh:1:cnt:bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb",
            "swh:1:cnt:cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc"
          ],
          "total_tokens": 0,
          "unchanged_components_reused": 2,
          "vertex_count": 2,
          "vertices": [
            {
              "card_id": "extract_json_schema_det",
              "deterministic": true,
              "input_type": "mcp_server_manifest/v1",
              "model_calls": 0,
              "output_type": "typed_tool_edges/v1",
              "source": "reused_card",
              "vertex_id": "v1_extract_json_schema_det",
              "vertex_kind": "loop"
            },
            {
              "card_id": "corner_case_fuzzer_det",
              "deterministic": true,
              "input_type": "typed_tool_edges/v1",
              "model_calls": 0,
              "output_type": "conformance_verdict_pack/v1",
              "source": "reused_card",
              "vertex_id": "v2_corner_case_fuzzer_det",
              "vertex_kind": "loop"
            }
          ],
          "zero_model_deterministic": true
        }
      ],
      "required_input_type": "mcp_server_manifest/v1",
      "required_output_type": "conformance_verdict_pack/v1",
      "summary": "Compose schema extraction and deterministic boundary fuzzing to produce a conformance report with zero model calls.",
      "title": "Verify MCP tool schemas and corner-case refusals",
      "zero_model_plan": {
        "beats_no_extra_material_baseline": true,
        "card_chain": [
          "extract_json_schema_det",
          "corner_case_fuzzer_det"
        ],
        "edges": [
          {
            "from_vertex": "v1_extract_json_schema_det",
            "to_vertex": "v2_corner_case_fuzzer_det"
          }
        ],
        "estimated_cost_usd": 0.0,
        "estimated_latency_ms": 53,
        "estimated_tokens": 0,
        "latency_ms": 53,
        "model_calls": 0,
        "plan_id": "plan_7c947b36b3acd818",
        "quality_score": 0.9884,
        "recommended_submission_lane": "lane_12_cheapest_pareto_solution",
        "savings_vs_baseline": {
          "model_calls_saved": 3,
          "tokens_saved": 11500,
          "usd_saved": 0.048
        },
        "source_bodies_loaded": 0,
        "swhid_chain": [
          "swh:1:cnt:bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb",
          "swh:1:cnt:cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc"
        ],
        "total_tokens": 0,
        "unchanged_components_reused": 2,
        "vertex_count": 2,
        "vertices": [
          {
            "card_id": "extract_json_schema_det",
            "deterministic": true,
            "input_type": "mcp_server_manifest/v1",
            "model_calls": 0,
            "output_type": "typed_tool_edges/v1",
            "source": "reused_card",
            "vertex_id": "v1_extract_json_schema_det",
            "vertex_kind": "loop"
          },
          {
            "card_id": "corner_case_fuzzer_det",
            "deterministic": true,
            "input_type": "typed_tool_edges/v1",
            "model_calls": 0,
            "output_type": "conformance_verdict_pack/v1",
            "source": "reused_card",
            "vertex_id": "v2_corner_case_fuzzer_det",
            "vertex_kind": "loop"
          }
        ],
        "zero_model_deterministic": true
      }
    }
  ],
  "chat_relay_template": {
    "fields": {
      "card_metadata_sufficient_without_source": true,
      "challenge_id": "ch_creative_motion_01",
      "expected_card_id": "synthesize_motion_det",
      "lane": "lane_13_retrieval_composability_feedback",
      "observed_top_card_id": "synthesize_motion_hybrid",
      "query_tested": "zero token parametric keyframe solver",
      "suggested_disambiguation": "Add deterministic zero-model trigger phrase to synthesize_motion_det."
    },
    "footer_fence": "--END-TELEON-SPARE-TOKEN-PROBE",
    "header_fence": "--TELEON-SPARE-TOKEN-PROBE",
    "record_type": "teleon_spare_token_probe_template/v1"
  },
  "cli_commands": {
    "best_composition": "loop-engine worker-pipeline arena --origin https://arena.teleon.dev --action plan_composition_menu --challenge-id ch_creative_motion_01 --objective-mode best_composition",
    "brief_retrieval_probe": "loop-engine worker-pipeline brief --origin https://arena.teleon.dev --lane lane_13_retrieval_composability_feedback --no-code-only --brief-out probe-brief.json",
    "cheapest_solution": "loop-engine worker-pipeline arena --origin https://arena.teleon.dev --action plan_composition_menu --challenge-id ch_creative_motion_01 --objective-mode cheapest_solution"
  },
  "engine_id": "contract_card_beam_composer_v1",
  "generated_by": "tools/build_composition_arena_record.py",
  "guide_address": "/guides/spare-token-composition-arena.md",
  "record_type": "teleon_composition_arena_surface/v1",
  "reusable_components": [
    {
      "component_kind": "contract_card_beam_composer",
      "summary": "Type-directed beam planner that chains small contract cards into Loop-only DAGs with zero source bodies loaded."
    },
    {
      "component_kind": "pareto_cost_minimizer",
      "summary": "Multi-objective Pareto filter ranking USD cost, tokens, model calls, and latency against the no-extra-material baseline."
    },
    {
      "component_kind": "zero_model_edge_bridge",
      "summary": "Deterministic schema adapter snapping two existing contract cards together with zero model calls (lane_14_edge_bridge_adapter)."
    },
    {
      "component_kind": "spare_token_retrieval_probe",
      "summary": "Volunteer search and composability benchmark verifier checking Recall@k, MRR, and planted gold controls (lane_13_retrieval_composability_feedback)."
    },
    {
      "component_kind": "sibling_confusion_disambiguator",
      "summary": "Negative-boundary and trigger-phrase patch generator separating near-duplicate cards without mutating executable digests (lane_02_confusion_repair)."
    }
  ],
  "revision": "bcc8eb53bf9681d0fd4b49b8ebebd517ea38d42053147f6b0bc27882d029ac0f",
  "royalty_buckets_bps": {
    "acceptance_oracle": 2000,
    "adversarial_breaker": 1500,
    "findability_confusion_packaging": 2500,
    "problem_spotter": 500,
    "seed_scout": 500,
    "solver_and_one_up": 3000
  },
  "sample_retrieval_probe": {
    "composability_gap_edges": [
      {
        "from_schema": "cad_brep_mesh/v1",
        "query": "convert step brep mesh into rigged gltf motion",
        "to_schema": "rigged_skeleton/v1"
      }
    ],
    "engine_id": "contract_card_beam_composer_v1",
    "gold_controls_checked": 1,
    "gold_controls_passed": 1,
    "lexical_miss_queries": [
      {
        "expected_card_id": "pack_gltf_rig",
        "query": "convert step brep mesh into rigged gltf motion",
        "top_returned_card_id": "extract_cad_brep"
      }
    ],
    "loop_model_calls": 0,
    "metrics": {
      "card_sufficiency_without_source_rate": 0.6667,
      "mrr": 0.5,
      "recall_at_k": 0.6667
    },
    "operation": "audit_retrieval_composability",
    "probe_attestation_digest": "fc8f99d613151ef3d926e66671831315cec4a766bc94131f984ee4e8f5f1474b",
    "provider_calls": 0,
    "q12_eligible_buckets": [
      "findability_confusion_packaging",
      "problem_spotter"
    ],
    "recommended_baton_payloads": [
      {
        "card_a": "synthesize_motion_det",
        "card_b": "synthesize_motion_hybrid",
        "target_lane": "lane_02_confusion_repair",
        "target_queue": "q08_confusion_repair",
        "trigger_query": "zero token parametric keyframe solver"
      },
      {
        "card_a": "pack_gltf_rig",
        "card_b": "extract_cad_brep",
        "target_lane": "lane_02_confusion_repair",
        "target_queue": "q08_confusion_repair",
        "trigger_query": "convert step brep mesh into rigged gltf motion"
      },
      {
        "executable_bytes_mutated": false,
        "suggested_trigger_query": "convert step brep mesh into rigged gltf motion",
        "target_card_id": "pack_gltf_rig",
        "target_lane": "lane_01_make_findable",
        "target_queue": "q07_describe"
      },
      {
        "from_schema": "cad_brep_mesh/v1",
        "target_lane": "lane_14_edge_bridge_adapter",
        "target_queue": "q04_solve",
        "to_schema": "rigged_skeleton/v1"
      }
    ],
    "record_type": "solution_composition_plan_result/v1",
    "reported_spare_tokens_spent": 4800,
    "sibling_confusion_pairs": [
      {
        "expected_card_id": "synthesize_motion_det",
        "outranked_by_card_id": "synthesize_motion_hybrid",
        "query": "zero token parametric keyframe solver"
      },
      {
        "expected_card_id": "pack_gltf_rig",
        "outranked_by_card_id": "extract_cad_brep",
        "query": "convert step brep mesh into rigged gltf motion"
      }
    ],
    "slot_id": "solution_composition_synthesis",
    "spare_token_budget_ceiling": 25000,
    "trial_count": 3
  },
  "slot_id": "solution_composition_synthesis",
  "surface": "/composition-arena"
}